Thales International

‘Zahid’s ignorance of leak raises more questions’

Defence Minister Ahmad Zahid Hamidi’s response of ignorance of leaked documents regarding the Scorpene submarine scandal in parliament last night has raised more questions than answers.

Lembah Pantai MP and PKR vice-president Nurul Izzah Anwar said such a response required further answers as Zahid himself had admitted there was an investigation on the matter.

“So what was the investigation’s scope? Were the police and the Attorney-General’s Chambers involved to avoid conflict of interest with the Defence Ministry?” she asked.

“Furthermore, the minister should also reply whether the ‘official’ documents in the French Court possession are not state secrets and hence false documents? If this is indeed the case, when will the government issue a diplomatic note to protest its usage,” the Lembah Pantai MP inquired further.

As the clock was ticking to midnight, Zahid said his ministry had no information about vital documents being leaked out to Terasasi Hong Kong Ltd, who sold Malaysian secret documents to Thint Asia, also known as Thales International, a subsidiary of DCNS, the company which sold the two Scorpene submarines.

Terasasi’s two directors are Abdul Razak Baginda and his father Abdullah Malim Baginda. Abdul Razak, who was acquitted of a charge of abetting the murder of Mongolian translator Altantuya Shaariibuu, is said to be close friend of Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak.

It was reported on May 31 that Terasasi was paid 36 million euros (RM142 million) for an evaluation by the Royal Malaysian Navy on the Scorpene submarines.

NONENurul Izzah (left) further queried if Zahid wished to clarify whether the purchase of the Scorpene submarines was a government-to-government initiative, and why there was a need to use a private company, Perimekar Sdn Bhd, for “support and coordinating services and not a government body.

“The minister must also list what those services (provided by Perimekar) actually are,” she asked.

She further questioned whether Malaysia’s submarines have had live fire and torpedo exercises done to test the weapons systems.

“Before Zahid attempts to hide behind the Official Secrets Act, take note that ‘live fire’ exercises such as the Exocet missiles from our naval ships and ‘missile test’ launches are public knowledge as part of proof of our capability and military posturing,” she inquired further.

Short URL: http://www.freemalaysiakini2.com/?p=35413







Posted by
on Jun 27 2012. Filed under News.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0.
You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

10 minutes to midnight, gov’t pleads ignorance

Defence Minister Ahmad Zahid Hamidi today told Parliament that his ministry does not know about allegations that state secrets had been sold to foreign countries.

“As far as the ministry knows, to date, there has been no detection of information being leaked out of Malaysia,” he said in his adjournment speech to Parliament about 10 minutes before midnight.

Parliamentarians debated through the night on the Budget supplementary bill before Zahid stood up to provide his promised explanation on the alleged leak in military secrets.

ahmad zahid hamidiHe said the ministry has “no information” about claims that Terasasi Hong Kong Ltd had sold Malaysian secret documents to Thint Asia, also known as Thales International, which is a subsidiary of DCNS, one the companies responsible for the sale of two Scorpene submarines to Malaysia.

“The ministry also does not have any information about claims that Terasasi received periodical payments from Thint Asia,” he said in his five-minute speech in response to Lembah Pantai MP Nurul Izzah Anwar.

Responding to queries by Nurul Izzah whether Malaysia would request to be an observer to the French tribunal on the Scorpene case to gain access to its investigation papers, Ahmad Zahid said this did not arise as there is no ongoing trial of the matter in France.

The French court – which adopts an inquisitive system – is currently at its investigation stage into alleged corruption by DCNS and has yet to proceed to trial.

‘No need for royal commission’

He added there was no necessity for the setting up of a royal commission of inquiry to scrutinise the 1.341 billion euro (RM5.3 billion) submarine purchase as it adhered to the Defence Procurement Procedure and Manual.

“It involved various stages of approval including at the technical committee and price negotiation committee after detailed evaluation was made to ensure it suited the needs of the Malaysian Armed Forces,” he said.

azlanFurther to this, the Attorney-General’s Chambers had also approved the contracts related to the purchase and all its terms and conditions were presented to the Finance Ministry for approval, said Ahmad Zahid.

He added that a parliamentary standing committee for defence procurement is also not required, because such procurements are laid out in the country’s budget, which is debated and passed by Parliament.

“Every expenditure is also subjected to the scrutiny and reprimand of Auditor-General’s Office.

“The government also views that the process of procurement which involves strategic defence equipment, should not be discussed openly,” he said.

Ahmad Zahid’s comments tonight were the first official response given to Parliament close to a month after the alleged sales of Malaysian defence secrets was revealed by human rights group Suaram in Bangkok.

Terasasi is alleged to have received 36 million euro (RM142 million) from DCNS for among others, the ‘sale’ of a highly confidential report comprising the Malaysian Navy’s evaluation for the order of the submarines.

Kyplex Cloud Security Seal - Click for Verification